
If you’re an avid reader—or even someone trying to get back into the habit—keeping track of your books can be both motivating and rewarding. But with so many book tracking apps out there, how do you know which one fits your style?
✍️ My Experience Using These Apps
While reviewing each of these apps, I also spent time personally using them—and here are a few thoughts based on that hands-on experience:
✅ Book Tracking Capabilities
All four apps let you create collections, shelves, or categories like “Want to Read,” “Currently Reading,” and “Finished.” Most also allow you to track “Did Not Finish”—either through a dedicated option or by creating a custom shelf or collection. If you’re the kind of reader who jumps between books or abandons some along the way (no judgment!), this is super helpful.
📲 Fable
- This one was the most challenging to import my reading list into—I lost about half of my titles during the process.
- I also had trouble finding some ebooks and was not able to manually add books, which was frustrating.
- Books had to be manually re-added to collections and shelves after import.
- But it’s not all bad—Fable includes a referral system so you can share with friends and earn credits toward ebooks.
🔗 Join Fable with my referral link
📚 Goodreads
- Goodreads makes it easy to share your bookshelf with others.
- You can invite friends to connect or simply show them what you’re reading.
🔗 Check out my Goodreads bookshelf
📈 The StoryGraph
- No shareable invite link (yet), but you can add friends manually and import from Goodreads.
- Surprisingly, the import was fast and accurate—it even auto-shelved most of my books correctly, which saved a ton of time.
- I loved the reading challenge options—you can track books, pages, or hours read.
- There’s a short survey to help tailor book recommendations based on your mood, pace, and genre preferences.
- While it may miss more obscure or “outlier” books, it does allow you to submit edits or add missing book info.
- You can also choose to support the app financially for bonus features—knowing it’s independent from Amazon makes this a worthwhile consideration.
💡 Final Takeaway
Each app has its strengths, quirks, and user base. If you’re looking for clean tracking and deep insights, StoryGraph stands out. If you’re craving community and reviews, Goodreads is still the go-to. For group reads and discussions, Fable might be your fit—just prepare for a little more manual setup. And for a more reflective, personal journaling experience, Bookmory shines quietly in the background.
Whatever your reading goals are—be it staying organized, finding community, or simply remembering what you read—there’s an app that can meet you where you are.
As far as a general comparison, keep reading below!
📖 Goodreads
Best for: Readers who want a large community and don’t mind a more traditional interface.
Pros:
- Massive database of books with detailed metadata.
- Easy to track your reading history, rate and review books.
- Annual Reading Challenge is popular for motivation.
- Large, active community with author Q&As and group discussions.
Cons:
- Owned by Amazon; limited updates over the years.
- Outdated user interface and clunky navigation.
- Limited data visualization or in-depth stats.
Good for: Readers who want a well-established platform with tons of reviews and basic tracking tools.
🧠 Bookmory
Best for: Readers who want to track reading habits, notes, and quotes more than engage socially.
Pros:
- Clean, minimalist design.
- Note-taking and quote-saving features built in.
- Tracks your reading time and provides graphs.
- More of a reading journal than a social platform.
Cons:
- Less about discovering new books or community sharing.
- Limited library compared to others—you may need to manually enter books.
Good for: Reflective readers who love journaling, stats, and reading insights over social interaction.
💬 Fable
Best for: Social readers who want to discuss books in private groups or public circles.
Pros:
- Emphasis on book clubs, group chats, and shared reading experiences.
- Curated book lists by authors and influencers.
- Beautiful user interface and intuitive navigation.
- Guided reading features with suggested pacing and discussion prompts.
Cons:
- Less robust tracking tools than StoryGraph or Goodreads.
- Smaller community and library, though growing.
Good for: Readers who love book clubs, group reads, and rich, interactive discussion.
📊 The StoryGraph
Best for: Data-loving readers and mood-based reading planners.
Pros:
- Clean, modern interface with detailed analytics (pages read, pacing, mood, genre).
- Personalized recommendations based on your reading habits.
- Allows half-star ratings and content warnings.
- Independent and not affiliated with Amazon.
Cons:
- Smaller community, fewer reviews per book.
- Occasional gaps in book availability, especially international titles.
Good for: Readers who want a more mindful and data-driven approach to reading—and value ethical platforms.
🧭 Final Thoughts: Which One Is Right for You?
- Choose Goodreads if you want a widely used platform with tons of reviews and don’t mind the dated look.
- Try Bookmory if you want to track personal reading habits, jot down quotes, and use your app more like a diary.
- Use Fable if book clubs and discussion are what motivate you most.
- Go with StoryGraph if you’re into detailed stats, mood tracking, and personalized recommendations.
Every reader’s journey is different. The best app is the one that helps you feel more connected to your reading goals—whether that’s building community, gaining insight, or simply remembering what you read.












